If using ice, add ice first to two small glasses or clear cups.
Pour Orange Fanta into pitcher. Add the cherry juice. Add the lemon juice. Stir to combine.
Divide the juice combination between the two glasses.
Drop in one gummy eyeball into each glass, ensuring it bobs near the top. Slide one gummy eyeball onto each straw and insert one straw into each glass.
Optional: Squirt a few drops of red gel food coloring onto one exposed eyeball for added drama.